Challenge coins have been part of military culture for centuries and are now popular in other industries as well. Consequently, challenge coin manufacturers continue to be in demand. Our top 10 challenge coin makers have been compiled to help you find the right one. So if you’re looking for the best challenge coin makers, read on to learn more about our picks!
1. Why use challenge coins?
While the history of challenge coins has always been shrouded in mystery and legend, today, challenge coins are taking on new life in a variety of novel uses while still maintaining a strong connection to the original challenge coin tradition as meaningful symbols.
Today, more and more people are using custom challenge coins to reward the achievements of their various teams, units, or departments. Whether it’s celebrating a level increase, a sales goal, outstanding customer service, or a milestone marking years of commitment, people find different reasons to award custom Challenge Coins to their team.
As the market-leading manufacturer of custom challenge coins since 2010, we have manufactured millions of custom challenge coins for all types of organizations, government agencies, clubs, businesses, and individuals. From Air Force challenge coins to custom police challenge coins, fire department coins, or brewery challenge coins, if you can think of it, we’ve probably made a coin for it.
（Another related post: Custom Challenge Coins: An Ultimate Guide)
2. 10 best challenge coin manufacturers
Below is a list of the 10 best challenge coin manufacturers of 2023.
Top 1: SICpin
Source: https://sicpin.com/challenge-coin/
Business Type: Challenge Coin Manufacturer
Established Year: 2009
Location: Zhongshan City, Guangdong Province
Products:
- Raptors Coin
- Police Coin
- Military Coin
- Naval Coin
- Troops Coin
- Business Coin
- Motivate Coin
- Honor Coin
- Enamel pin
- Medal
- Band charm
- and more
Design options:
SICpin offers two basic manufacturing processes: zinc alloy die-casting or brass stampings. Your challenge coin production is handled by our professional design team and customer service department. Prior to production, you will approve details such as material, size, Pantone color, metal plating, packaging, etc.
Order size:
You can order any amount of Challenge Coins through SICpin. They have no minimum order quantity required. Everything depends on your needs.
Online ordering process:
this is very simple. You consult SICpin’s website to get a quote, then provide the challenge coins you want to customize and the order quantity. They will produce it immediately after receiving your order.
Price:
The cost of challenge coins depends on the size of the coins you want, the options you choose, and the quantity you want. SICpin’s prices are very stable and competitive. Cost-cutting and profit-boosting assistance.
Turnaround time:
Turnaround time is quick, usually around 12-15 days. A design’s complexity ultimately determines how long it will take.
Comment:
You can see what customers have said about it on the SICpin website, and all of them are positive. This proves its reliability.
SICpin is a professional pin manufacturer in China, specializing in manufacturing and designing pins for more than 12 years. It can provide customized services based on customers’ drawings or ideas and help you design for free, which can save you a lot of energy. Just sit back and wait for your shipment to arrive. There is no minimum order quantity, no matter how many pieces you need. Quotes are clear and there are no extra costs.
Top 2: THIN BLUE LINE USA
Source: https://www.thinbluelineusa.com/
Business Type: Manufacturers of clothing, accessories, and custom challenge coins.
Established Year: Not specific
Location: Michigan, America
Products:
- Men’s Clothing
- Women’s Clothing
- Clothing accessories
- Challenge Coin
- Emblems
Design options:
THIN BLUE LINE USA offers custom challenge coins, with their expert art team customizing one-of-a-kind challenge coins for police departments, firefighters, and various other agencies across the country.
Order size:
There is no minimum order requirement and you can get the quote information by filling out the form on their official website.
Online ordering process:
Contact them and tell them what you think, and the designer will create a sketch based on your idea. A digital sample is then provided for your reference. Once approved, production begins.
Price:
As low as $3.75 each
Turnaround time:
Fast turnaround, optional production time.
Comment :
Over 5,000 positive reviews are displayed on their website.
THIN BLUE LINE USA is a Michigan-based non-profit organization that helps families of the fallen, first responders, and veterans. So far, they have donated more than $1 million. THIN BLUE LINE USA can tailor challenge coins to customers’ needs, including beautiful packaging. In addition, he offers free on-site service for every order.
Top 3: Monterey Company, Inc.
Source: https://www.montereycompany.com/
Business Type: Manufacturer of high-quality metal products
Established Year: 1989
Location: Bend, Oregon
Products:
- Custom Hats
- Patches
- Lapel Pins
- Challenge Coin
- Medals
Design options:
The Monterey Company designs custom products for its customers with specialized manufacturing processes, as well as offering antique silver/bronze and various patina finish options.
Order size:
There is no minimum order requirement and you can get the quote information by filling out the form on their official website.
Online ordering process:
You agree to The plan after consulting the quote on their website, and The Monterey Company will send you the invoice information for review and final production.
Price:
The cost of challenge coins depends on the quantity and material you want, contact them for detailed quotation information.
Turnaround time:
Depending on the customer’s custom product, it is usually 3 to 4 weeks.
Comment:
Google has hundreds of positive reviews from customers.
Founded in 1989, Monterey Company, Inc. has over 30 years of experience in challenge coin manufacturing. Has a professional expert design team and a variety of manufacturing processes, such as molding, laser engraving, screen printing, etc. It is committed to providing customers with first-class products and the best quality service.
Top 4: SIGNATURE COINS
Source: https://signaturecoins.com/
Business Type: Custom challenge coin manufacturer
Established Year: 2000
Location: America
Products:
- Police challenge coin
- 3D Challenge Coin
- State coins
- Army Challenge Coin
- United States Marine Corps
- U.S. Air Force coins
- Super Challenge Coin
Design options:
Their artists build one-of-a-kind designs based on the concepts and images you submit. The more information and comments you can provide, the better. Within 48 hours, you will receive a full-color digital proof via email. If you are not satisfied with your custom coin design, simply request modifications and they will happily make changes until you are happy with your challenge coin design.
Order size:
The minimum order quantity is 50 coins. They cannot offer a price below the minimum order. Due to the effective cost of designing and manufacturing unique coins, the minimum number of coins they can create in a single run is 50 coins.
Online ordering process:
Send them your ideas and fill out the quote form. If you would like to speak with one of their representatives, you can call or send an email. Any questions you may have will be answered by one of their sales professionals.
Within 48 hours, their artist will send you a design proof (via email). If you like the art you receive, please order a quote online or by phone.
If you would like to see any design modifications, please send them an email detailing the changes you would like to see along with any reference images or sketches you think would be helpful to their art staff. Once payment has been received, your order will be confirmed.
Price:
More specifically, it is dependent. A challenge coin’s cost is determined by a variety of factors, such as its size, quantity, and color. Color is often determined by the organization’s coat of arms or logo and the brand standards surrounding it. Coin size will be determined by complexity, industry requirements, and personal desires.
You can view their pricing schedule on their website.
Turnaround time :
Once payment is made, production will begin. You should receive your challenge coins within 14 days of payment.
Comment:
The site has a lot of user reviews. All the feedback has been very good. The site has a lot of user reviews.
Since its founding in 2000, the Lapel Pins R Us Network has created a thriving network of online businesses known for high-quality personalized badges and promotional products, at a time when others thought the Internet would be the Fashion. They decided it was time to change their name and brand to better reflect the company’s size and scope, as well as its continued commitment to customers as a market leader in every category.
The new name of the company, Signature Promotional Group, denotes quality. Not only that, you can also find a variety of promotional products that allow you to put your personal stamp on every marketing or promotional campaign you launch.
Top 5: Popularpins
Source: https://www.popularpins.com/
Business Type: Pin manufacturer in China
Established Year: Over 20 years
Location: Kunshan, China
Products:
- Lapel Pins
- Challenge Coins
- Medals
- Belt Buckles
- Patches
- Lanyards
- and more.
Design options:
Popoppins offers a custom challenge coin service and offers a variety of dyeing options to match customers’ personalized themes.
Order size:
There is no minimum quantity required, contact them for detailed pricing information.
Online ordering process:
Clients inform them of their ideas, and then a team of professional designers design and draft patterns for them. Production will begin after the two sides confirm the error.
Price:
Each challenge coin has a factory price of approximately $0.132.
Turnaround time:
3-5 days.
Comment:
Customers can read reviews on their website and all reviews are positive.
Headquartered in Kunshan, China, Popoppins is the only challenge coin manufacturer in China with a factory and control. At present, it has a plant area of 10,000 square meters more than 300 employees, and more than 200 professional production equipment. Can meet the customized needs of any customer. Its service philosophy is to provide customers with first-class products at the most favorable prices and provide the most comprehensive purchase services.
Top 6: Challengecoinsltd. com
Source: https://www.challengecoinsltd.com/
Business Type: Custom challenge coin manufacturer
Established Year: 2011
Location: Florida
Products:
- Military Challenge Coin
- Firefighter coin
- Football currency
- Ford Challenge Coin
- U.S. Army custom military coins
- Helicopter Challenge Coin
Design options:
Before placing your order, they will provide you with a full-color digital proof based on your design input. If there’s something you don’t like about your personalized coin design, they’ll keep tweaking it until you’re happy.
Order size:
The minimum order for their custom challenge coins is typically 100 pieces. However, they can produce smaller quantities and adjust unit prices if needed.
Online ordering process:
After receiving your free quote or confirmation of your artwork, you can place your order through their online order form.
Price:
Whether the coin is a unique design or a reflection of an existing coin design, the price of a custom coin is determined by a number of criteria. Their website has price lists based on different materials and designs.
Turnaround time:
Most orders are processed, packed, and shipped within 7-10 business days, which means your coins will arrive in about two weeks, if not less.
Comment:
They have trusted verified reviews on their website. They have 1775 reviews there. Most of them are positive. A 4.9-star rating has been given to them.
Challenge Coins Ltd. is pleased to offer unique challenge coins that are manufactured to the highest quality standards while being affordable. You can celebrate and record your team members’ achievements for a low cost – but their Challenge Coins aren’t cheap.
You can use their business challenge coins to motivate employees, impress and connect with customers, or reward your suppliers for their efficiency and reliability, in addition to their military challenge coins. Challenge coins make a lovely keepsake, very unique, and will be cherished for years to come.
（Another related post: What is FBI Challenge Coins – A Complete Guide)
Top 7: Quality Challenge Coins
Source: www.qualitychallengecoins.com
Business Type: Custom challenge coin manufacturers
Established Year: Over 20 years
Location: Colorado
Products:
- Military Coins
- Police Coins
- Fire and EMS Coins
- Motorcycle coins
- Challenge coin
- and more.
Design options:
Quality Challenge Coins offers customization of challenge coins in a variety of metals, finishes, and styles.
Order size:
No minimum order requirements
Online ordering process:
First, fill out a free quotation and send it to them, then their design team turns your ideas into production-ready proofs for you to review. Final production.
Price:
Fill out their free form to get a quote
Turnaround time:
About 10 working days.
Comment:
Quality Challenge Coins has over 100,000 satisfied customers and you can see 1,231 five-star reviews on their website.
Quality Challenge Coins has over 20 years of experience in manufacturing challenge coins. It has a trained team of expert designers and guarantees that every coin is made of the highest quality materials. It is committed to providing unique products for each customer. To date, it has produced millions of challenge coins for government agencies, companies, and various organizations around the world.
Top 8: Custom challenge coins
Source: https://customchallengecoins.net/
Business Type: Challenge coin design & production
Established Year: 2003
Location: America
Products:
- Activity coins
- Sports currency
- Corporate Challenge Coin
- Club currency
- College coins
- Commemorative coins
- Government Challenge Coin
- Firefighter Challenge Coin
- Police coins
- Military Challenge Coin
Design options:
Artwork is completed quickly; you can get a quote and design in as little as 24 hours. Their designers create incredible designs that are always unique to you, and they won’t stop until you’re completely satisfied.
Order size:
The minimum order quantity for coins is 25. You are free to order any quantity as long as the minimum requirements are met. There are various price discounts based on quantity, which can save you a lot of money.
Online ordering process:
The ordering process is quick and easy. Fill out the quote form to get a free, no-obligation quote, or email their sales department. You will hear back from them within 12 hours. You can also call them to place an order.
Price :
While they make every effort to keep the website up-to-date and accurate, prices may change at any time. By design, a price list with charts is provided.
Turnaround time :
Products are delivered within 14-21 days.
Comment:
They have customer reviews that shoppers approve of. Most of them are 5-star rated, which means their customers are satisfied with their services.
They are very happy with your coin project and what it means to you in Custom Challenge Coins. They recognize what your coin symbolizes. The team at this company is committed to providing the best quality and service in the industry.
Many of their customers have something in common with their creative and customer service staff. Many of their crew members are veterans or have family members who have served in the military. They back up their claim that they understand challenge coins with their expertise and services. Let their experts handle your coin needs and they guarantee you won’t be dissatisfied.
Top 9: Strike Your Coin
Source: https://strikeyourcoin.com/
Business Type: Canada’s best custom challenge coin manufacturer
Established Year: 2017
Location: Canada
Products:
Customize various challenge coins
Design options:
Strike Your Coin offers challenge coins in a variety of sizes ranging from 1.5 inches to 3 inches in diameter, and includes a variety of colors, edge text, 3D images, and a variety of shapes.
Order size:
There is no minimum quantity.
Online ordering process:
Send them a request for a quote or an email, then send the relevant customization information to get a free customization service. Finally, put into production.
Price:
Depending on the size and number of coins, the more you order, the lower the cost.
Turnaround time:
A variety of production times for you to choose, from to achieve delivery within the specified time.
Comment:
You can read customer reviews on their website, and all of them are positive.
Founded in 2017, Strike Your Coin is one of the best challenge coin manufacturers in Canada. With a professional design team, often the client only needs to send them sketches and preliminary ideas to complete the design. It provides rapid response and full service to customers through telephone, email, and online chat. At present, it has cooperated with schools, government agencies, organizations, and so on.
Top 10: US DOD Coins
Source: https://usdodcoins.com/
Business Type: Military coin supplier
Established Year: 2012
Location: America
Products:
- U.S. Air Force Challenge Coin
- US Army Challenge Coin
- U.S. Navy Challenge Coin
- US Marine Corps Challenge Coin
- U.S. Coast Guard Challenge Coin
- U.S. Space Force Challenge Coin
- Law Enforcement Challenge Coin
- Fire Challenge Coin
- EMS Challenge Coin
- Corporate Challenge Coin
Design options:
They have many options to choose from. If you want a custom coin, you must submit your artwork. If you do not have any artwork, please briefly describe what design you would like on your coin before submitting an offer.
Order size:
The minimum quantity is 100
Online ordering process:
Their ordering process is quick and easy. All you have to do now is place your order and wait for the digital proof after selecting all your requirements. Afterward, you must approve the digital proof. When you give them approval, they will start production immediately.
Price:
Although its coin prices may vary, U.S. Department of Defense Coins guarantees that its customers receive high-quality coins at the best prices. They take pains to maintain a coin pricing structure that explains the affordability of their coins and offers a variety of unique military and law enforcement coin design alternatives.
The coin size, no color, single or double-sided color, and special add-ons such as medallion ribbon attachments, 3D imaging, offset printing, cutting, etc. are just some of the rigorous coin design options you can choose from.
Turnaround time :
They deliver within ten business days.
Comment:
They have a lot of great feedback on their website. These are real customer reviews who were very happy with the quality, customer service, and service.
The US. DOD COINS, a premier military coin supplier, offers a wide range of possibilities for crafting quality custom coins, bottle openers, badges, and dog tags. They start with brass/zinc as the base metal and then plate it with gold, silver, or other creative platings. If you want to add a splash of color to your product, they use the highest quality enamel paint to create beautiful handheld trophies that are built to last.
Each coin or badge is carefully engraved and hand-painted to suit your needs. You can customize your own coin or have one made for you. It is possible to recreate any service badge, patch, logo, emblem, or seal.
（Another related post: Military Challenge Coins 101: All You Need to Know)
3. Some tips for creating challenge coins
Here are some tips for creating challenge coins.
1) Consider the role and purpose of a token and explore the concept of your token.
You first need to determine what the theme of your challenge coin is, such as a corporate anniversary or military reward, what concept graphics, logos, and text need to be included, and pay attention to the overall style of your challenge coin’s graphics and text. Own coin time.
2) Pay attention to the actual proportions of the coin and draw the pattern proportionally.
If you are troubled by the size of the challenge coin, it is recommended that you first find a challenge coin of similar size and measure the size. In addition, you should pay attention to the size and size of the pattern on the coins when you design them yourself or have them designed for you by some websites free of charge.
For scale, you can ask the designer to send you the graphic design for review. If you find it too troublesome, you can also choose some challenge coin websites that already have ready-made templates.
3) The choice of craftsmanship for personalized coins is very important.
For example, choose electroplating, imitation enamel, multi-color, double-sided, coin edge decoration, 2D plane, or 3D plane. Even the packaging of the product is also important. You need to check the actual product pictures on those websites for reference. If there are 3D patterns on the website, it will be more realistic and clear, and have more reference value.
4) Localize your design.
If you need to design it yourself directly, there are some challenge coin companies that can support your online design on their websites, such as SICpin.com. Go over each design carefully, send in your ideas early, and try to let the website provide you with a 3D Challenge Coin mockup pattern.
Because many websites designed for you support modifications, if you want to receive your coins before a certain date, you need to communicate with the designer in advance and constantly check to find errors in patterns or text and correct them.
Asking the website to provide you with a 3D challenge coin model pattern is also the best way for you to double-check your challenge coin, as this 3D model is great for viewing the texture and detail of the challenge coin and is the closest to the real challenge coin product.
（Another related post: How to Acquire Challenge Coins)
4. Conclusion
Challenge coins are gaining traction as a popular trend, and many companies are now producing challenge coins to boost team spirit and increase brand loyalty. There are various designs, sizes, and shapes for customers to choose from. One thing is for sure, you have many options when looking for a challenge coin maker to customize your coins.
It is crucial for managers to recognize their employees, and this task can help strengthen their relationships. Additionally, it plays an important role in improving team morale and satisfaction.