Die Struck Pins vs. Enamel Pins: Which Custom Lapel Pin is Right for Your Needs?

Lapel pins are small but powerful tools in branding, recognition, and promotions. Whether you're honoring achievements, promoting a cause, or enhancing your brand's image, selecting the right type of custom lapel pin¹ is crucial. Among the options available, die struck pins and enamel pins stand out for their distinct styles and purposes. This article will help you understand the differences and choose the best pin for your needs.

Die struck pins offer timeless elegance with metallic finishes, perfect for formal recognition and corporate awards. Enamel pins provide vibrant colors and modern designs, ideal for promotions and casual branding. Choose based on your needs, budget, and desired aesthetic.

When deciding, it’s essential to align the choice with your branding goals, audience preferences, and budget. Let’s explore these two pin types in depth to ensure you make the most informed decision.

---

Understanding the Unique Benefits of Die Struck Pins and Enamel Pins

What Are Die Struck Pins?

Die struck pins² are custom-crafted metal pins made using a stamping process. A die is pressed into a metal sheet, leaving raised and recessed areas that form the design. These pins don’t feature color but instead rely on metallic textures and finishes like polished, antique, or sandblasted effects.

Key Characteristics of Die Struck Pins:

• No Color Fill: Designs are showcased through metal textures and raised details.
• Available Finishes: Options include gold, silver, antique bronze, and more.
• 3D Possibilities: Perfect for highlighting intricate reliefs like buildings, characters, or actions.

Common Uses:

• Corporate awards and logo pins
• Service recognition and commemorative pins
• Event badges requiring a vintage or formal appearance

Real-World Example:
The United States Military extensively uses die struck pins to signify rank, service, and achievements. These pins, crafted with high-quality metals like brass or copper, are integrated into uniforms as insignias, showcasing pride and accomplishment while maintaining a formal aesthetic.

What Are Enamel Pins?

Enamel pins are vibrant and colorful, filled with enamel paint in recessed areas. There are two types: soft enamel and hard enamel³. Soft enamel offers a textured finish, while hard enamel provides a smooth, polished look.

Key Characteristics of Enamel Pins:

• Colorful Designs: Ideal for artistic restoration or modern graphic logos.
• Durability Variations: Hard enamel is more durable than soft enamel.
• Flat or Textured Finishes: Depending on the type, enamel pins can be flat (hard enamel) or textured (soft enamel).

Common Uses:

• Promotional giveaways
• Artistic and collectible designs
• Casual branding efforts

Real-World Example:
Creative brands like The Gray Muse use enamel pins to appeal to artistic audiences. For instance, their "Bird of Paradise Floral Enamel Pin" showcases vibrant colors and intricate details, leveraging soft enamel’s flexibility for eye-catching designs that resonate with creative individuals.

---

Pros and Cons of the 2 Types Pins

Pros of Die Struck Pins

1. Timeless Elegance: The absence of color highlights the natural beauty of metal, making them suitable for formal occasions.
2. Durability: With no enamel, there’s less risk of chipping or scratching.
3. Cost-Effective: Die struck pins don’t require color filling, reducing production complexity.
4. High Detail Precision: Perfect for intricate designs like logos or commemorative items.

Real-World Example:
The National Parks Service uses die struck lapel pins to commemorate special events and recognize staff contributions. For instance, their 100th-anniversary pins featured antique finishes, offering durability and a timeless aesthetic.

Cons of Die Struck Pins

1. Limited Design Complexity: Without color, the focus is solely on metal textures.
2. Less Visual Vibrancy: May not appeal to audiences seeking bold, colorful designs.

Pros of Enamel Pins

1. Vivid Design Options: Bright colors make logos and artwork pop.
2. Versatile Applications: Suitable for fashion⁴, promotions, and casual branding.
3. Customizable Shapes and Sizes: Offers flexibility in design.

Cons of Enamel Pins

1. Potentially Less Durable: Soft enamel is prone to chipping without epoxy coating.
2. Higher Costs: Enamel application and polishing increase production time and expense.

Real-World Example:
Independent Etsy sellers frequently create enamel pins featuring pop culture references and artistic designs. These pins often use hard enamel for a polished, jewelry-like finish, appealing to niche markets and collectors.

---

Choosing the Right Pin for Your Needs

Factors to Consider

Aspect	Die Struck Pins	Enamel Pins
Purpose	Corporate events, formal awards	Promotions, casual giveaways
Budget	Cost-effective, no enamel required	Slightly higher due to color application
Aesthetic	Classic, vintage metal look	Modern, colorful designs
Durability	Highly resistant to wear and tear	Hard enamel is durable; soft enamel less so

Use Case Examples

• Die struck pins: Ideal for recognizing years of service or creating formal event badges.
• Enamel pins: Perfect for trendy product launches, fandom collectibles, or artistic designs.

---

Customization Options

Both of the 2 types pins offer various customization possibilities, allowing you to align the design with your brand identity⁵.

Die Struck Pins:

• Finishes: Choose from polished gold, antique bronze, or sandblasted effects.
• 3D Designs: Create detailed reliefs for a striking impression.
• Sizes and Shapes: Custom die molds can produce unique shapes.

Enamel Pins:

• Color Matching: Use Pantone colors⁶ to ensure brand consistency.
• Special Effects: Add glitter, glow-in-the-dark finishes, or screen printing.
• Backings: Options include butterfly clutches, magnetic backs, and more.

Real-World Example for Die Struck Pins:
Coca-Cola uses die struck lapel pins for employee recognition programs, celebrating milestones with polished finishes that enhance brand loyalty.

Real-World Example for Enamel Pins:
Quinn Spins emphasizes the use of enamel pins as promotional tools, helping brands engage customers with colorful, eye-catching designs at trade shows and events.

---

Conclusion

Choosing between die struck pins and enamel pins depends on your goals, budget, and audience. Die struck pins deliver timeless sophistication, ideal for formal events or recognition awards. Meanwhile, enamel pins offer vibrant, versatile designs perfect for modern promotions.

Whatever your choice, investing in high-quality custom lapel pins ensures your message stands out. Start exploring your options today and elevate your branding or recognition efforts with a pin that speaks volumes.

---